Saturday, August 17, 2013

Boiler - Firebox Section

Revised:   April 25, 2014          Subject to Revisions

Assembling The Firebox And Attaching To Boiler - 4/25/2014

Once all the firebox parts were printed the next step is to assemble the overall firebox in preparation to attaching it to the rest of the boiler.  The first step was to bond the lower rivet panels to the main structure.

Rivet Panels Held In Place While Super Glue Hardens
 
 The above picture shows where the front of the main structure will attach to the rear of the steam dome section after grinding and trimming with the engineer and fireman side rivet panels.  The rubber bands keep the panels in place while the super glue hardens, about 15 minutes or so. 

Firebox Section With Rear Panel Being Glued
 
The next step was to glue the rear firebox panel that eventually will be inside the cab in place using super glue.  Again the rubber bands hold it in place until the glue sets up.  So far alignment is very good.

Preliminary Fit Check Of Air Baffle and Clinker Chute
 
Before gluing the air baffle and clinker chute in place a preliminary fit check revealed that the boiler support just after the rear drivers was too high and needed to be ground down.  Also, the clinker chute was too long also.  Finally the front cab support interfered with the rear of the boiler and needed to be relocated a bit further back. 


After Adjustments the Firebox Section is Attached to the Existing Boiler
 
Once the adjustments were made to the boiler mounts at front and rear of firebox section that section was was glued to the rest of the boiler.  Once again rubber bands were used to hold the firebox to the rest of the boiler while the glue set up and hardened.  At the point shown in the picture above the air baffle and clinker chute was already glued in place at the bottom of the firebox section completing it's assembly.

The tape measure in the photo shows that the locomotive alone is about two feet long.  The tender will perhaps be about 60% of that length or so.  The overall model will be a bit over three feet long.

All Five Boiler Sections Assembled

Bottom View of Assembled Boiler Showing Clinker Chute at Bottom of Firebox

Side View of Firebox Section


Pressure Relief Valve Glued to Top of Firebox Section

At this point the boiler is ready to have the hold down screws placed to keep the boiler in place when the model is handled.

Boiler Hold Down Screw Assembly and Placement - 4/25/2014

The front hold down screw was designed to be accessed through the smoke stack while the rear hold down screws were to pass through the rear frame into the clinker chute.  One problem became apparent right away, small cross point screwdrivers were not long enough to reach the front hold down screw through the smoke stack and further locating the front hold down screw could not readily be located well enough for my patience. 

A screw holder and driving device was designed and added to the parts list along with an extension at the bottom of the smoke stack to guide the screw in place.  The two bosses put on the clinker chute worked well and just fit inside the rear frame.  These would be co-drilled with a tap size drill bit for 2-56 screws. 

The front screw was already a 4-40 screw drilled and tapped into the cylinder saddle at the center ready for the hold down screw to pass through a boss inside the smoke box section.  I could have opened the smoke box front and placed the screw in place OK, but the screw drivers readily available would not reach it down through the smoke stack.

3D Printed Parts Of Front Hold Down Screw Extension as Printed

Front Screw Hold Down Extension Parts After Clean-up

Screw Extension Laying Down With Screws and Smoke Stack Extension Standing up
 
The front hold down screw extension consists of a top screw, an extension rod, the bottom hold down screw and screw retainer that holds it to the extension rod are show in the above photo along with the smoke stack extension that will surround the extension rod and keep it approximately aligned with the hole through the bottom boss and into the cylinder. 

Preliminary Fit Check of Parts with Smoke Stack

 

After Assembly of the Extension and Smoke Stack Extension

Overall Assembly of Extension Inside Smoke Stack Extension
 
After assembly of the parts it was observed that once the smoke stack is glued in place, the extension cannot be removed through the smoke stack but remains inside the smoke box approximately in the correct location for attachment.  The protruding screw at the right passes through the boss at bottom of the smoke box section into the cylinder saddle threaded hole.  It does take a bit of fiddling to align the screw in the hole at the bottom of the smoke box section and to get the screw driver into the cross point screw at the top of the rod down through the smoke stack, but it works!

Once the front hold down extension was completed and the boiler attached to the cylinder the rear screw holes were drilled through the rear frame into the bosses on either side of the clinker chute to attached the rear of the boiler in place using 2-56 screw hardware.  This was done in two steps, first drill with a #51 tap size drill bit through the frame and boss, then remove the boiler, tap the holes in the clinker chute and drill clearance holes for the 2-56 screws through the frame.

Rear Boiler Hold Down Screws Through Rear Frame Into Clinker Chute Bosses

Top of Screw Extender Seen Through Smoke Stack
 
Boiler down is now complete and other details can be now designed and added.  The next project will be the locomotive cab that will be attached to the firebox section and probably have a removable top to gain access for the tender drawbar attachment and probably some cab details to be added later.

A number of other boiler and chassis details are called for as well such as headlight, bell, generator, compressor, walkways, grab bars, air tanks and pistons under the walkway, many pipes and tubes, etc.  Some of the small items will such as hand rails and tubes will probably be made from either small metal or plastic tube.

More details are needed on the chassis as well such as the front coupler, ladders up to the walkways at the sides of the engine and some of the under cab details such as the water pumps and piping in that area.

I might start on design of a tender using a set of 7 1/2" gauge live steam plans I have for a C&O mikado.  In another blog I have been reporting progress making a "G" gauge aluminum version from the C&O plans starting with the wheel sets for the trucks.  The 3D printed version for this larger 1/24th scale model can lift those and rescale them for the ABS tender model to go with this locomotive engine. 

Finally a Reasonable Pressure Relief Valve - 4/18/2014

Switched from Axon 3 to Axon 2 version of the .stl file conversion software and got decent a decent part printed.  I have had good success with small parts in past with it.  The Axon 3 version of larger parts works better than those done with Axon 2 generally.

Axon 3 version in rear, Axon 2 version in front of Pressure Relief Valve

For some unknown reason the Axon 3 printed many small protrusions all over the part and did not fully fill out some portions of the part correctly.  Axon 2 did a much better job making this quite small part, about 7/8" long, 5/8" high and 3/8" thick.  Fortunately I did not do away with Axon 2 when Axon 3 became available.  Axon 3 compiles the part print program much, much faster and has a few more options, but has trouble with small parts as shown above.

I will now clean up the parts and assemble the firebox section.  Some preliminary fittings on the locomotive frame indicate that some trimming and adjustments will need to perhaps be made.  The frame rear hold down bolt holes need to be located, drilled and tapped.  A new hold down bolt assembly for the front down the smoke stack needs to be fabricated and checked that will permit easier alignment of the bolt at the bottom of the smoke box section that goes into the cylinder assembly.  This is part of the smoke box section of the boiler and will be reported in another blog entry.

Also, the springs need stiffening and the spring U clamps need to be glued to the spring ends to keep them in place while handling the model.  This is work on the chassis and will be reported in another blog entry.

Finally Having Success Making Firebox Parts With Modified 3D Printer - 4/16/14

After modifying the BFB-3000 printer with the heated Z platform and learning how to make and use ABS Glue, most of the parts for the firebox have been made successfully needing only some cleanup and/or patching with filler to clean up holes, etc. 

The general plan for the firebox section consists of making seven parts in all and gluing them together to make the entire firebox section.  The assembled firebox section will then be glued to the rear of the steam dome section to complete the bulk of the boiler, less most details such as pipes, walkways, etc.

3D CAD View of Completed Firebox Section

The CAD view above shows the intended firebox assembly that will be attached to the previously built boiler sections.  The locomotive cab will later be attached to this section.  The firebox section is composed of seven parts shown in the exploded view below.

Exploded View of Firebox Section of Boiler

The firebox section consists of 1) main structure, 2) engineer side rivet panel (top right), 3) fireman side rivet panel (left center), 4) Back panel (right center), 5) Air intake baffle (middle below main structure), 6) Clinker Chute (bottom middle) and 7) Pressure relief valve (top middle).  These parts will be glued to the main structure before attaching the firebox section to the rest of the boiler.

Main Structure After Clean-up

Air Intake Baffle after Printing before Clean-up

Rear Panel After Printing before Clean-up

Engineer and Fireman Side Rivet Panels After Clean-up

Clinker Chute After Printing Before Clean-up


The pressure relief valve is a very small part, I have attempted it twice now with no good results, just a mangled mess.  I had used Axon 3 conversion software for it as had been done on the other parts with no success.  I will try using Axon 2 conversion software as that had success in making many small parts in past.

I have been delinquent in keeping up the blog, and the building of the model as well due to family affairs that have prevented regular work.  I hope to accelerate my pace now as the problems are quieting down and I should have more time to build.   The next blog entry to the firebox section should show assembly details and perhaps attachment to the boiler.


Modifying My BFB-3D Touch 3D Printer With a Heated Build Platform

Been having so much trouble with my original build platform that I broke down and ordered a heated glass platform kit from GRM Products, Hudson, New Hampshire.  It comes with the platform ready to install with all parts except the 3 tie wraps as one assembly, wire cables and all.  It took about 1/2 hour to install and worked right out of the box, heated that is.  Great start. 

BFB Touch 3D Printer With GRM Products Heated Glass Build Platform

Although the platform now heats (which may cure the problem of large part build warpage and tendency to lift of the build platform), it was quickly discovered that even relatively small parts would not stick to the platform.  I went to the web, mainly on YouTube and found out many suggestions including using Kapton tape, blue painters tape (original), ABS glue and various other methods.

I tried using blue tape and it melted!  I found out that I was using the new 3M Exterior blue tape AND that I had set the heads to close to the glass bed.  I then tried original 3M blue painters tape it stuck well to the glass of course and the test article stuck very strongly and stayed flat.  I had run all test prints at 110 degrees C. 

A Couple of Test Prints Directly on Heated Glass Bed
 
The small parts at left stayed on the glass, but came with almost no effort.  The larger folded glob on the right was built on 3M Exterior Blue Tape and came off during the run just after the first few layers.  It folded up under the print heads as shown.  It has enough ABS layers to be very stiff and can not be unfolded.  The glass bed side is very, very smooth.  All the tape under the part had been melted or removed from the glass bed mainly sticking to the part that fell off during the run.



Test Piece Made on Original 3M Blue Painters Tape

Obtained a 2" wide roll of the original 3M Blue Painters tape and attached adjacent strips on the bed with little or no gaps between strips.  Folded the ends over so they would not stick to the glass outside the heated area so I could easily grasp the strips for removal after the run.  Used powder free Latex medical exam gloves to avoid getting finger oils on the part side of the tape strips.

The resulting piece was experimental made with Axon 3 build code software from BFB (Bits From Bytes, now part of 3D Systems).  The white ABS uses new novel support posts and the part itself was a 1/16" thick step pattern with a few holes to evaluate the ability to build thin parts this way.  The part stuck very strongly to the blue painters tape without using any form of glue.  It may be that certain glues should be used to reduce the stick.  I also calibrated the "Z" axis of the printer so that a slight gap existed between the extruder nozzles and the surface of the blue tape.  I believe the gap can be even greater based on the extreme stick of the white ABS to the blue tape.  I was able to remove the part using the thin metal removal tool provided with the printer OK.  It took some patience and a fairly strong push in many places around the part before it finally came off. 

A residue of tape glue was left on the glass surface.  It came off readily with a few minutes soak with Windex glass cleaner.  I scraped the glass clean using the removal tool with it's flat straight edge and wiped the glass clean with a clean dry cloth.

The next test will be to try a much bigger part, I'm considering going back to the baseline firebox design, removing the rivet detail on the sides, thinning the sides to permit later attachment of flat panels with the rivet detail and making the whole firebox in one piece as was originally planned.  Only the back panel that goes inside the cab and the relief valve assembly would left off as was originally planned as well.  They, along with the clinker chute would be added later to complete the entire firebox.

I hope to report more often assuming that the new heated bed works well allowing big and little parts to made more readily.

 

Preparing The Firebox Core For Attachment to Boiler - 10/25/2013

The round core for the firebox had raft and support material (white) attached that needed to be removed.  The firebox core has a reduced diameter rim so that it will fit into the steam dome section just in front of the firebox. 

The firebox core has a reduced lower diameter so that the lower flat sides for the firebox and bottom portions can later be aligned as they are attached.

Firebox Round Core Temporarily Attached to at Rear of Boiler

Rear View of Boiler Core Temporarily in Place

Side View of Locomotive model With Firebox Core in Place

The next actions will be to design and fabricate the remaining sections of the firebox; flat lower sides, bottom firebox front, clinker chutes at bottom, rear of panel of firebox.  The intent is that all of the firebox parts will be bonded together with glue and the entire assembly bonded in place as shown in the above photos. 

The sides of the clinker chutes will be located between the rear frame members.  Bosses on those chutes will be drilled and tapped to accept screws that will go through holes in the rear frame to hold the rear of the boiler assembly in place on the locomotive frame.   There is already threads for a single screw that holds the front of the boiler to the cylinder assembly at the front.  That screw is accessed down through the smoke stack.

 

Success Finally Printing Key Part of Firebox - 10/9/2013

Tried to print the firebox as a single large part, no success, then tried a number of sections, no success either.

Seven Trials to Print Firebox
 
The large white base in the middle was the only portion of the file that printed on the 3D printer before it separated from the platform.  The process was aborted.  The two side frame white bases with a bit of black part did the same, separated from the platform.  The two upright black curved sections in the middle were attempts to print portions of the firebox top section, no success, separated before completion, but got closer.

Decided that since the previous sections of boiler were round that a round section of the top with slightly downsized bottom round might print OK.  The round rings on either side of the semi-round sections were that round portion, their bases separated as well.

Readjusted the 3D printer to print the base thinner on the platform to promote adhesion. 

Successful Print of the Firebox Fully Round Section

The fully round section shown above has the rounded top portion that is exposed and a rounded bottom section that is reduced in size a bit to allow the rectangular sides and bottom to be attached after they get printed.  The taper of the top is inside the cab and will have the back of the boiler after it gets printed.  This portion of the firebox still is to be removed from the white base. 

As can be seen in the ruler this portion is about 4" in diameter.  The height of the highest portion of the tapered top is nearly 5" tall. 

Time Gap in Blog - 8/17/2013

It's been a good long while between the previous blog post and this one.  Many issues arose that forced a postponement.  Bypassing other personal issues, one issue regarding the 3D printer is worth mentioning.

About two months back the printer kept jamming the feed into extruder #1, on the left side.  I cleaned, reloaded, and did many things to no avail, it would feed a few feet of material and stop feeding as if it were jammed.  I gathered that perhaps the extruder temperature was a bit too low.  This could be caused by several things such as the control board, cables to the extruders, heater or sensor on the extruder.  It could also be caused by something jamming the extruder on the inside.

The first thing I tried was to switch the control cables on the the control board so that the signals that had gone to extruder #1 went to extruder #2 and vice verse.  My thinking was that extruder #2 worked fine and if the control board or cables were an issue it would cause the problem to reverse.  If the problem was with the extruder it work as before.  After the switch and another reloading of material, the exact same result occurred.  After feeding a few feet into extruder #1 it would stop feeding while extruder #2 would feed normally.  The problem was therefore with the extruder itself.

I contacted the manufacturer, Bits from Bytes in the UK and layed out the problem and what I had done to diagnose the problem.  A few messages back and forth to clarify my findings and verify things for the technician ensued after which the manufacturer sent me a new hot section of the extruder and pointed out where I could find the instructions to disassemble and reassemble the extruder portion.

I installed the new hot section on extruder #1 and after a few false starts managed to get everything going again and low and behold the extruder was now fully operational. 

All this effort took about a month which diverted me from the locomotive build project.  As I mentioned I also had a number of time consuming personal issues that forced me to halt the project.  I also encountered one of my old nemesis problems with the print while trying to build the firebox section of the boiler.

Initial Attempts To Build The Firebox Section

Since the 3D printer was able to build the relatively large boiler sections previously, I felt that it should be possible to build the firebox as well.  The firebox is quite different however from the essentially round sections done previously.  The bottom is rectangular in cross section and that portion juts out in front of the round upper section.  This means that the 3D printer would build a relatively large support structure for the round section.  Another issue is that the firebox rear is not at a right angle and has a hole for the firebox door.

Basic shape of the firebox section, less rivet detail
 
The initial rough design used internal 45 degree walls to support the back wall to eliminate the need for supports.  This was done to reduce print time.  This configuration would have used nearly a half-spool of plastic and taken some 84 hours to print according to the Axon 2 build code builder program.  This was excessive so further work was done on the design to reduce material.

 

Firebox section with rivet detail
 
Before doing the reduced material configuration the rivet detail was done on the base design.  This resulted in enormous design and build file sizes and even more build time.   I wasn't intending to use this configuration anyway.

Modified Firebox design to save material and print time
 
The interior of the design was carved out to reduce the use of material.  A big contributor was the separation of the rear panel to a separate print effort.  The design is nearly five inches wide, five inches tall and seven inches long.  It would be stood up on the front for printing.

Rear panel of revised Firebox design

The rear panel of the improved design has flanges to simplify alignment during assembly.  It also has the firebox door opening.  It is about five inches wide by six inches tall.

Attempts at Printing the Firebox

I had no luck printing the large firebox part standing up.  The raft and support portions lifted of the 3D printer platform early on due to the very large size and prevented continuation of printing.

Raft and Support after failure to adhere to the printer platform

The jagged strands of material and a thick blob at the top of the circle occurred when the raft/support separated from the platform before I noticed the problem.  The ruler gives an idea of the size of the item.  In the past round rafts for the prior boiler sections remained attached and provided a base for the large round sections to be built without problems.  Not so this time.  I also tried printing in other directions with no luck.

An attempt to print a side wall before the printer was repaired

The side wall above highlighted the feed problem before the printer was repaired.  In this case the black material was being printed by extruder #1.  It would feed only a fairly small amount and then stop feeding. 

Another attempt to build the side wall when the extruder stopped feeding

All the rafts lifted on the long flat structures.  The author has experienced this problem before and went to building long items vertically.  That was done in the firebox case as well, however the very large raft lifted away. 

The author is now planning to break up the firebox into smaller pieces and glue them together after build.  This will result in joint lines but cannot be avoided.

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Boiler - Sand Dome and Steam Dome Sections

Revised:  4/13/2013            Subject to Revisions

Sand Dome and Transition Boiler Section

The author elected to build the sand dome section and a tapered transition section between the sand dome and steam dome sections as one piece.  This part would be a near maximum Z axis height capability of the 3D printer.  The success with the smoke box section prompted this decision.  The design looks as follows from the Alibre Solid Modeling CAD software.

Sand Dome and Taper Section Part
 
The section is near 7 1/2" when standing up on end.  The part is a bit over 4" diameter at the wide end of the tapered section.  The design has a wall thickness of about 0.1" and a flange at the the front end that provides an inside joint between the sand dome section and the smoke box section just forward.

View of the Sand Dome and Taper Section Composite in 3D Printer

View of Composite Sand Dome and Taper Sections

After 25 hrs 49 min the 3D printer completed the composite section.  The ruler in the photo above shows the model section is over 7" tall.  Inspection of the model section shows fairly good definition.  The sand dome section at the top has two mounting holes built in for sand dome alignment and installation.  The sand dome itself is a separate model part to be built separately.  This is the largest part made on the 3D printer so far.  The part is very rigid and strong, barely flexing even under considerable pressure.  The upper reduced diameter portion is a flange that nests inside the smoke box section.

Sand Dome and Taper Section CAD Model with Sand Dome in Place

The 3D CAD model above shows the sand dome in position on the front of the composite section.  The sand dome will be built next.

View of Composite Sand Dome and Taper Section Fit Checked With Smoke Box Section


Sand Dome

The sand dome part is fairly large and curved to fit on the boiler section.  An attempt to build the sand dome as a single part was made with the top up.  The support material where the thin lower edges were to be located separated preventing the model bottom most edges from forming.  The print was stopped.  The author then did a notional design splitting the dome in halves along the radius of the boiler curve.  The author contemplated putting the two halves in a structural box to permit grinding the joint flat on the mill.  This did not work out either, once again the support edges lifted preventing the outer box frame from starting on the support material.

View of a Split Half of the Sand Dome

Author's Notional Design of a Structural Frame Around A Pair of Sand Dome Halves

The red structural frame shown around the pair of sand dome halves was to provide a way to support the dome halves during milling.  The large frame required a large support structure which separated before the frame started printing.  The author stopped the print cycle and went back to the drawing board.

Two Successful Sand Dome Halves

Sand Dome Halves With Support Material Along Joint Ends

Top and Bottom View of Sand Dome Halves Before Removing Support Material

The sand dome halves each took 6 hr 15 min to print.  Both came out quite well with a small tendency of the support material to lift at the access side of the printer.  The detail was as expected with the sand fill covers showing good detail.  Each half has a pin extending down into the respective hole in the sand dome section. 

The support material was removed and the center joint cleaned up with the Dremel sanding wheel.  The joined boiler sections are shown fit checked on the locomotive chassis below.


Fit Checking of Joined Smoke Box, Sand Dome and Taper Sections on Chassis

Steam Dome Boiler Section

The steam dome section is very similar to the smoke box section except slighter larger in diameter and having the steam dome instead of smoke stack. 

Steam Dome Section Design Illustration From 3D CAD Software

The print time of the steam dome boiler section was 10 hr 43 min.  The wall thickness and forward flange were similar to the front portion of the sand dome and taper composite section.  The print quality and part sizing were similar to that experienced in both the smoke box and sand dome composite sections.  Not shown is separate view of the new section.  The steam dome section was joined to the previous sections for a fit check on the locomotive chassis.

View of the Completed Boiler Sections Fit Checked on Locomotive Chassis

The fit checks clearly show that the boiler mount flanges on the locomotive chassis fit correctly with the boiler.  They will not be secured to the boiler.  The boiler will be secured to the chassis using a single screw accessed down through the smoke stack and one or two screws at the rear, location TBD.

Steam Dome

Steam Dome Just After Printing


The steam dome is a very curved shape which took a few hours of 3D CAD work to develop the model.  The author decided to print the dome directly on the raft material rather than first build a layer of support material as had been done on most other printing efforts.  After 3hr 37min the dome was printed.  It was done solid as it is fairly thin compared to the sand dome for instance.  The printed article came out well with some of the support material lapping over on the top.  Two pins were printed on the bottom to mate with the two holes printed in the boiler.

Steam Dome Being Fit Checked on Boiler

The dome fit well on the boiler.  An interesting result of using the 3D printer is that the complex curved shapes all fit very close and required little trimming to mate with the boiler.  It's a bit of design work to achieve the compound curved shapes, but the 3D printer did a very good job with them.

Locomotive Boiler With Domes During Fit Checks

Four of the boiler sections are now completed along with the smoke stack, sand dome and steam dome.  The next portion of the boiler the author will tackle will be the firebox section.  This is a fairly complex shape that will have a ring on the front to mate inside the steam dome section and flat sides extending downward from roughly the center line of the boiler axis.  The back end is tapered somewhat.  The cab will surround the back end with the tapered portion inside.  The flat sides below where the walkway will be located will have many detail bolts that connect the outside of the water jacket around the actual firebox inside. 

The design of the firebox section will also eventually have the ash chutes attached that go down thru the opening in the rear frame.  Those will be made separately and attached to the firebox during assembly.