By modifying the 3D design model the axle and drivers fit together much better. A modest amount of filing and grinding were done to optimize the fit. The wheels slide snugly unto the axle. The picture at left shows one pair and axle completed and the second pair awaiting printout of one driver as this blog entry was written.
The wheel gauge is off a bit, somewhat too wide for the design goal of 1/2" to the foot of american standard gauge of 4' 8 1/2". The axle length will be adjusted to bring the gauge closer to scale dimension.
The approach being taken is to now build sample PLA parts on ABS raft and support structure, check fit and key dimensions, adjust the design to correct any significant errors and build new parts. This seems to be working. It will take longer and use more material, however, the machine repeats build sizes fairly well and it appears that this method can achieve the desired scaling.
The drivers built for the above picture are used for the front and back pair of the Mikado locomotive. Two other sets are needed, the intermediate pair and the main pair. Before assembly of the driver and axle sets, the bearings need to be fabricated and slipped on the axles.
Sunday, December 4, 2011
Friday, December 2, 2011
Another Attempt at PLA part on PLA raft
A second attempt to fabricate PLA parts on a PLA raft with PLA supports was made. The Wheel-Axle Kit was used with revised axle diameter and axle hole diameter. The ensemble is shown at left after build. The raft was made thicker in order to obtain a better release as was experienced with the axle part on the previous build.
After the build an attempt was made to remove the raft and supports using finger and later pliers pressure. As for the previous build, the axle was removed relatively easy while the raft under the wheels was again attached very strongly making removal essentially impossible. A short effort was made using a Dremel tool and cutter tool to remove the white PLA material. It of course is ground away, but only slowly and with very little control. It would likely require a tool more precise such as a milling machine to remove the raft material. This build method is impractical for large flat parts like the wheels.
After the build an attempt was made to remove the raft and supports using finger and later pliers pressure. As for the previous build, the axle was removed relatively easy while the raft under the wheels was again attached very strongly making removal essentially impossible. A short effort was made using a Dremel tool and cutter tool to remove the white PLA material. It of course is ground away, but only slowly and with very little control. It would likely require a tool more precise such as a milling machine to remove the raft material. This build method is impractical for large flat parts like the wheels.
Wednesday, November 30, 2011
Wheel and Axle "Kit" second attempt
After revision of dimensions of the axle diameter and axle hole in the driver wheels, a 2nd run was instituted. Because the axle was so difficult to remove from the raft and supports, it was elevated above the raft in an attempt to obtain an easier release. The view at left shows the kit immediately after printing while still on the printer Z platform.
After removal from the printer the raft under the wheels and the thick support structure under the axle are clearly visible. The raft and support are clear PLA while the wheels and axle are black PLA. It took 6 hr and 32 minutes to build this set of parts. At first impression the top surface was about equivalent in finish as the first run, but somewhat more strings of black material were evident. The strings are not a problem as they can easily be removed.
Raft and support removal was attempted as before using finger pressure or a needle nose pliers. The thick support under the axle readily came off with finger pressure leaving the axle nearly free of clear PLA material. The wheels were another story, however. The clear PLA maintained a tenacious hold to the wheel and rod crank areas. Removal resisted extreme measures using both a needle nose and side cutter pliers. A clear layer of PLA is clearly shown in the view at left. The axle however does seem to fit much better than previously. Measurements will still need to be made to verify that both parts approach their design accuracy. Another run will be attempted using a much thicker raft and support under the wheels as well as the axle in the belief that it may be easier to remove all parts from the raft and support base.
After removal from the printer the raft under the wheels and the thick support structure under the axle are clearly visible. The raft and support are clear PLA while the wheels and axle are black PLA. It took 6 hr and 32 minutes to build this set of parts. At first impression the top surface was about equivalent in finish as the first run, but somewhat more strings of black material were evident. The strings are not a problem as they can easily be removed.
Raft and support removal was attempted as before using finger pressure or a needle nose pliers. The thick support under the axle readily came off with finger pressure leaving the axle nearly free of clear PLA material. The wheels were another story, however. The clear PLA maintained a tenacious hold to the wheel and rod crank areas. Removal resisted extreme measures using both a needle nose and side cutter pliers. A clear layer of PLA is clearly shown in the view at left. The axle however does seem to fit much better than previously. Measurements will still need to be made to verify that both parts approach their design accuracy. Another run will be attempted using a much thicker raft and support under the wheels as well as the axle in the belief that it may be easier to remove all parts from the raft and support base.
Monday, November 28, 2011
Axle post build processing results
Both the end up and diameter down axles were post processed using a hand file and Dremel tool sanding wheel. Both were improved in diameter smoothness and consistency. The end up version raft end bulge was reduced from an oversize condition of 0.045" to 0.021". It was hard to judge when the axle was uniform, however, it should be possible to improve it more by making measurements during the effort. The top end was not processed and remained oversize by 0.010".
The diameter down axle version initially was oversize by 0.0265" and 0.0207". The raft attachment area was very rough due to removal using a side cutter pliers. The file was used to make the attach point smoother and more uniform. This was followed by use of the Dremel tool sanding wheel to improve roundness along the attachment area. The final result was 0.0131" and 0.0142", considerably a better match than was obtained with the end down axle.
In recap, the axle holes in the two driver wheels were 0.0173" and 0.0187" undersized. The combination results in an interference of approximately 0.04" using the end down axle and 0.033" using the diameter down method. Since the diameter down axle results in better uniformity between the ends, it appears that the Wheel-Axle Kit would benefit by reducing the axle diameter about 0.0176" and increasing the wheel axle holes by 0.022". This should result in an axle diameter closer to target of 0.0412" with a clearance between the wheel hole and axle diameter of a few thousandths of an inch. Careful post processing should result in a reasonable slide fit suited for bonding using glue.
The driver bearing parts will also need to have their axle hole adjusted to clear the axle sufficiently to permit easy rotation without binding. However, due to the extensive amount of support required, it would be better to build the bearings using the ABS raft and support which is more easily removed using needle nose pliers or fingers.
The diameter down axle version initially was oversize by 0.0265" and 0.0207". The raft attachment area was very rough due to removal using a side cutter pliers. The file was used to make the attach point smoother and more uniform. This was followed by use of the Dremel tool sanding wheel to improve roundness along the attachment area. The final result was 0.0131" and 0.0142", considerably a better match than was obtained with the end down axle.
In recap, the axle holes in the two driver wheels were 0.0173" and 0.0187" undersized. The combination results in an interference of approximately 0.04" using the end down axle and 0.033" using the diameter down method. Since the diameter down axle results in better uniformity between the ends, it appears that the Wheel-Axle Kit would benefit by reducing the axle diameter about 0.0176" and increasing the wheel axle holes by 0.022". This should result in an axle diameter closer to target of 0.0412" with a clearance between the wheel hole and axle diameter of a few thousandths of an inch. Careful post processing should result in a reasonable slide fit suited for bonding using glue.
The driver bearing parts will also need to have their axle hole adjusted to clear the axle sufficiently to permit easy rotation without binding. However, due to the extensive amount of support required, it would be better to build the bearings using the ABS raft and support which is more easily removed using needle nose pliers or fingers.
Issues in building locomotive axles
The axle built during fabrication of the wheel axle kit run exhibits a noticeable bulge and roughness at the bottom end where the axle came into contact with the raft and support. The support was necessary for a small overhang due to presence of the keyway indentation at the bottom. Another keyway is at the top however it had a floor instead of an overhang and almost no distortion was present. The majority of the axle diameter is around 0.422" while the bulge was 0.457". The design target is 0.412",
Another axle was built laying down along the diameter using PLA raft and support with PLA build material. A narrow layer of clear PLA raft material proved much more difficult to remove requiring side cutter and other tools. After removal a narrow flat region exists on the portion of the diameter where the axle came into contact with the raft. The diameter along the axle was more consistent and did not exhibit the bulge seen during the previous build. The diameter was approximately 0.43" over the entire length. The diameter is still oversize from the design diameter of 0.412". It is probably worth building another axle with ABS raft material since it seems to separate more readily from PLA than does the clear PLA raft material from the black PLA build material.
These two parts will also provide test cases for post build processing to improve the uniformity of the axle diameter. This will probably be accomplished using a Dremel tool. No attempt to reduce the overall diameter to the design diameter, only to make the part more uniform in diameter. Since both the axle and wheel axle hole are off in opposite directions, the axles will not fit into the wheel at all. Consequently, the design will need to be revised to enlarge the wheel hole target dimension and the axle target diameter. By taking into account the relative errors reported previously, it should be possible to adjust the part build dimensions so that the axle will fit into the wheel axle holes.
Another axle was built laying down along the diameter using PLA raft and support with PLA build material. A narrow layer of clear PLA raft material proved much more difficult to remove requiring side cutter and other tools. After removal a narrow flat region exists on the portion of the diameter where the axle came into contact with the raft. The diameter along the axle was more consistent and did not exhibit the bulge seen during the previous build. The diameter was approximately 0.43" over the entire length. The diameter is still oversize from the design diameter of 0.412". It is probably worth building another axle with ABS raft material since it seems to separate more readily from PLA than does the clear PLA raft material from the black PLA build material.
These two parts will also provide test cases for post build processing to improve the uniformity of the axle diameter. This will probably be accomplished using a Dremel tool. No attempt to reduce the overall diameter to the design diameter, only to make the part more uniform in diameter. Since both the axle and wheel axle hole are off in opposite directions, the axles will not fit into the wheel at all. Consequently, the design will need to be revised to enlarge the wheel hole target dimension and the axle target diameter. By taking into account the relative errors reported previously, it should be possible to adjust the part build dimensions so that the axle will fit into the wheel axle holes.
Friday, November 25, 2011
Building a PLA model on PLA raft and supports
A PLA model was built using PLA raft and supports. The wheel axle kit was used which includes a right side and left side driver and the interconnecting axle. At left the picture shows the model upon completion in the BFB-3000 3D printer. Natural (translucent clear) PLA was used for the raft and supports while black PLA was used for the model proper. The build cycle was 6 hr 33 minutes. The axle is standing on one end between the two wheels.
After removal from the printer the supports appear nearly transparent as shown at left. Initial inspection indicated good resolution of both wheel flanges and good finish and surface continuity, much better than was obtained previously using a PLA raft with ABS model material.
The model parts were readily removed from the raft and supports, generally more readily done using a needle nose pliers. Wheels and axle at left are shown alongside the removed raft and support materials. Some black PLA thin flash materials were also found and easily removed.
At left is one wheel photo made using a flash. Certain edges strongly reflected light. The overal wheel finish is quite smooth and generally semi-gloss black.
The axle was quite uniform in diameter except near the bottom where the keying feature required support material. The axle in that region appears bulged. The axle will require post processing to obtain a uniform diameter throughout it's length.
The other wheel photo was also taken with flash lighting and again has reflections due to the glossy surfaces.
The next step will be to measure the parts and determine how accurately the parts conform to the design dimensions. A preliminary fit check revealed that the axle will not fit into the wheels unlike the ABS parts. The ABS wheel axle kit run resulted in an undersized axle enough to permit a fair fit on one wheel and a very loose fit on the other. The axle will ultimately be bonded to the wheels, however, the fit should be close to preclude misalignment as much as possible.
After removal from the printer the supports appear nearly transparent as shown at left. Initial inspection indicated good resolution of both wheel flanges and good finish and surface continuity, much better than was obtained previously using a PLA raft with ABS model material.
The model parts were readily removed from the raft and supports, generally more readily done using a needle nose pliers. Wheels and axle at left are shown alongside the removed raft and support materials. Some black PLA thin flash materials were also found and easily removed.
At left is one wheel photo made using a flash. Certain edges strongly reflected light. The overal wheel finish is quite smooth and generally semi-gloss black.
The axle was quite uniform in diameter except near the bottom where the keying feature required support material. The axle in that region appears bulged. The axle will require post processing to obtain a uniform diameter throughout it's length.
The other wheel photo was also taken with flash lighting and again has reflections due to the glossy surfaces.
The next step will be to measure the parts and determine how accurately the parts conform to the design dimensions. A preliminary fit check revealed that the axle will not fit into the wheels unlike the ABS parts. The ABS wheel axle kit run resulted in an undersized axle enough to permit a fair fit on one wheel and a very loose fit on the other. The axle will ultimately be bonded to the wheels, however, the fit should be close to preclude misalignment as much as possible.
Accuracy Analysis of PLA Bearing Part
Each driver wheel has a bearing that rides up and down in a slot of the chassis frame. The bearing surrounds the axle near each wheel. On top of the bearing is mounted a spring connecting plate that couples the load from the driver to the chassis through a set of equalization levers.
Four copies where made during the Small Parts Kit build. The picture at left shows the parts which have been numbered for the accuracy analysis.
The picture at left shows the bearing parts next to a ruler for size reference. The bearings are 0.81" X 0.95" width and length. Each has an axle hole of 0.42" target dimension.
The table above provides a comparison of design dimensions for key features vs. measured values averaged over the four parts. Statistics were also computed that measure the dispersion (sigma) and likely range of values (Error +/- 3.3*sigma) that may occur for other copies of the bearing that may be built in future. As can be seen the greatest error arose building the axle holes. Those are noticeably undersized. The next largest error arose with the slot that interfaces with the chassis. The slot span side to side is oversize by a bit over 5%. Other key dimensions are also in error as shown. In order to compensate for the errors either post processing (drilling, sanding, etc.) would need be performed, or alternatively, modify the design to adjust those dimensions in the opposite direction in an attempt to obtain better accuracy. Perhaps both will be needed for some parts that are expected to move in respect to one another as will be the case for the bearing in which the driver axle rotates and the bearing itself moves up and down in the chassis as the equalization scheme adjusts for small irregularities in the track, as is done on the prototype.
The chart above summarizes the nominal and predicted range of possible errors based on the statistics of measured values for key features of the four bearing assemblies. The green squares are the average errors while the red bars depict the range of possible errors based on the application of sigma variance to the averages. Corrections to the design dimensions should reduce and center the error bars around zero. However, several of the dimensions have rather large error bars which might prove difficult to use without considering post machining of the parts. On the other hand, it is not always necessary to obtain tight fit tolerances. The primary objective will be to ensure parts stay together and those that move do so without slipping off or out of position. In the end it will be necessary to build and fit check actual parts, not just designs.
The preceding chart shows the trend of bearing model errors vs. size of feature. It appears that feature sizes of approximately 1/2" are most accurate, those having lower dimensions tend to be undersized and those greater tend to be oversize. Charts such as these will aid in developing methods to obtain suitable accuracy for critical features that must interface with appropriate precision, such as moving parts.
Four copies where made during the Small Parts Kit build. The picture at left shows the parts which have been numbered for the accuracy analysis.
The picture at left shows the bearing parts next to a ruler for size reference. The bearings are 0.81" X 0.95" width and length. Each has an axle hole of 0.42" target dimension.
The table above provides a comparison of design dimensions for key features vs. measured values averaged over the four parts. Statistics were also computed that measure the dispersion (sigma) and likely range of values (Error +/- 3.3*sigma) that may occur for other copies of the bearing that may be built in future. As can be seen the greatest error arose building the axle holes. Those are noticeably undersized. The next largest error arose with the slot that interfaces with the chassis. The slot span side to side is oversize by a bit over 5%. Other key dimensions are also in error as shown. In order to compensate for the errors either post processing (drilling, sanding, etc.) would need be performed, or alternatively, modify the design to adjust those dimensions in the opposite direction in an attempt to obtain better accuracy. Perhaps both will be needed for some parts that are expected to move in respect to one another as will be the case for the bearing in which the driver axle rotates and the bearing itself moves up and down in the chassis as the equalization scheme adjusts for small irregularities in the track, as is done on the prototype.
The chart above summarizes the nominal and predicted range of possible errors based on the statistics of measured values for key features of the four bearing assemblies. The green squares are the average errors while the red bars depict the range of possible errors based on the application of sigma variance to the averages. Corrections to the design dimensions should reduce and center the error bars around zero. However, several of the dimensions have rather large error bars which might prove difficult to use without considering post machining of the parts. On the other hand, it is not always necessary to obtain tight fit tolerances. The primary objective will be to ensure parts stay together and those that move do so without slipping off or out of position. In the end it will be necessary to build and fit check actual parts, not just designs.
The preceding chart shows the trend of bearing model errors vs. size of feature. It appears that feature sizes of approximately 1/2" are most accurate, those having lower dimensions tend to be undersized and those greater tend to be oversize. Charts such as these will aid in developing methods to obtain suitable accuracy for critical features that must interface with appropriate precision, such as moving parts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)















